AI文档版本对比：删掉“借用电脑”，就等于取消服务吗？
同一份内部活动通知的两个版本交给ChatGPT、Gemini和Claude，三个回答都发现了电脑借用说明被删除，却没有直接认定服务已取消。真正的差别在于，它们接下来建议检查什么，以及结果是否方便交给同事。
这次选ChatGPT作为发送前的工作清单
WekeyLab AI选择ChatGPT的表格作为底稿：旧内容、新内容和需要修改的位置并排展示，还保留了没有变化的饮食需求截止日期。它提醒同步修改日历邀请和会议室预订，把文字改动连接到同事实际依赖的信息。
这不是只有一个服务找到变化的案例。Gemini用较紧凑的列表找到了相同的变更主题，并建议检查录像权限。Claude也找到了变化，提醒核对实际预订的房间，但面对英文输入回答了韩文。交给英语团队使用前，这份回答需要翻译。
先写好两个版本，再固定检查标准
我们自行编写了虚构的内部工作坊通知。活动日期2026年10月16日、上午9点开始、8:30签到、40人名额以及自带电脑都没有变化。报名段落和日程段落调换了顺序，但段落移动并不表示名额发生变化。
新版本把报名截止从10月9日17:00提前到8日中午，把结束时间从12:00延长到12:30，把204室改成402室。饮食需求由邮件改为内网表单，截止仍为10月12日。候补由自动加入改成主动选择。录像由全体员工可看30天改为报名者可看14天，并新增活动后向全体员工提供幻灯片。电脑借用说明则直接消失了。
提交之前固定十项核对标准，三个新对话收到完全相同的英文请求，不限制回答长度或格式。这次检查的是粘贴文本的版本差异，不是上传文件或扫描PDF的识别能力。
三个AI都没有把文句删除当成政策取消
旧版本说报名时申请即可借用电脑，新版本只要求自带电脑。能确认的是说明被删除，不能据此知道主办方停办了服务，还是编辑时误删了句子。
ChatGPT要求确认借用是否取消或被误删；Gemini建议确认政策是否仍存在、是否需要补回说明；Claude同样要求确认是否有意删除。这一项没有必要硬分胜负，三个回答都把应当询问主办方的问题留了下来。
ChatGPT的优势在于下一步怎么做
四列表格便于对照较早的报名截止、较晚的结束时间和新房间号。饮食需求两侧都写了10月12日，让人看清只有提交渠道变了。它算出报名截止提前一天五小时，我们独立计算的结果也是29小时。
更实用的是提醒修改日历邀请、房间预订、报名页面和附件日程。通知写了402室，日历却仍然显示204室，依旧会把人带错地方。这些是待办建议，并不是AI已经替团队修改系统。
Gemini检查权限，Claude检查房间
Gemini建议确认录像平台能否将访问限制为报名者、持续14天。这是合理的操作检查，因为改文字并不等于配置权限。不过它把“Join waitlist”称为复选框，而输入只说选择这个选项，没有说明控件类型。看过真实表单前，用“选择”更准确。
Claude强调了录像对象和期限的缩减，并建议确认房间是否真的预订为402室。它返回韩文这一现象被原样保留，没有为了改善比较而重新提问。英文输入没有明确要求英文输出，所以我们没有把语言算成事实错误；如果结果要交给指定语言的团队，最好明确输出语言。
Gemini和Claude没有重述不变的10月12日饮食需求截止日。这是上下文省略，不是错误修改了日期。三个回答也都没有完整单列所有未变项目，因此不能把它们当作逐项确认全部条件的签核记录。
WekeyLab AI整理的通知草稿
下文按给定的新版本整理。发送前仍需主办方确认电脑借用政策，我们没有擅自承诺可借或不可借。日期和时间保留原虚构活动的当地安排，不是换成中国举办的新测试。
团队工作坊｜2026年10月16日 活动时间09:00至12:30，地点402室，08:30开始签到。 请在10月8日中午前通过内网表单报名，名额40人。满员时，请在表单中选择“Join waitlist”加入候补。 请自带电脑。饮食需求请在10月12日前通过内网表单提交。 录像仅向报名者开放，活动后可看14天。幻灯片将在活动后向全体员工开放。 [编辑发送前检查：确认电脑借用政策，必要时补充准确说明，并删除本条编辑备注。]
下次比较可以这样提问
让AI把文档证据与需要向负责人确认的问题分开，比要求它写得更长更有用。下面是WekeyLab AI的改进模板，并未在本次测试中再次运行。发布前还要核对真实表单、日历和权限设置。
下方相关的会议纪要对比讨论了把未来承诺标成完成的问题，周末工作回复对比则讨论了无意中增加承诺的问题。它们与版本比较共有一个要求：文字要保留原有条件。
请用中文比较旧版和新版，列出修改、新增、删除的信息以及对应原文。把确认的文字变化与需要询问负责人的问题分开，不要仅凭删除一句话就推断政策取消。标明容易忽略但没有变化的日期和条件，最后给出发布前检查清单。
来源与实际记录
2026年9月18日09:02—09:03 KST，三个新网页对话各提交一次相同英文虚构输入，不限长度与格式。ChatGPT Free，Think关闭、模型名未显示；Gemini Flash，套餐未核实；Claude Free，Sonnet5中等。前两者用英语回答，Claude用韩语回答，原因未确定。保存原文1730、1491、806字符，包含空白换行，去除界面和进度文字后核对指纹。提交前固定十项标准，另存独立文本差异和截止时间计算。没有测试实际发送、权限配置、PDF识别或节省时间。韩中版本是同次实测的本地化，不是另外运行。查到相关英语搜索结果，但美国搜索量未知。
Related: AI meeting notes comparison / 회의록 비교
Related: weekend work replies / 업무 요청 답장 비교
ChatGPT · 2026-09-18 09:02-09:03 KST
I'm updating our team's internal workshop announcement. Compare the old and new versions and tell me what changed and what I should update before sending it to colleagues. OLD VERSION Team workshop — October 16, 2026 The workshop runs from 9:00 a.m. to noon in Room 204. Check-in opens at 8:30 a.m. Register by October 9 at 5:00 p.m. using the intranet form. Capacity is 40 people. Bring your laptop. Loaner laptops are available if requested when registering. Send dietary requests to [email protected] by October 12. If the workshop is full, you will automatically join the waitlist. The recording will be available to all employees for 30 days after the workshop. NEW VERSION Team workshop — October 16, 2026 Capacity is 40 people. Register by October 8 at noon using the intranet form. The workshop runs from 9:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. in Room 402. Check-in opens at 8:30 a.m. Bring your laptop. Send dietary requests through the intranet form by October 12. If the workshop is full, select "Join waitlist" in the intranet form. The recording will be available to registered attendees for 14 days after the workshop. Slides will be available to all employees after the workshop. Here’s the change list I’d use as a pre-send checklist: Item Old New What to update Registration deadline Oct. 9, 5:00 p.m. Oct. 8, noon Update deadline everywhere Workshop end time 12:00 p.m. 12:30 p.m. Update schedule/calendar details Room Room 204 Room 402 Update location Loaner laptops Available if requested during registration Not mentioned Confirm whether loaners are no longer available or were accidentally omitted Dietary requests Email [email protected] by Oct. 12 Intranet form by Oct. 12 Remove the email instruction and direct people to the form Waitlist Automatically joined if full User selects “Join waitlist” Update instructions so people know they must actively opt in Recording access All employees, 30 days Registered attendees, 14 days Update both audience and availability period Slides Not mentioned Available to all employees after workshop Add this to the announcement Things I’d verify before sending Loaner laptops: This is the only old detail that disappears without an explicit replacement. Confirm whether loaners are still available. Intranet form: Make sure the form actually supports dietary requests and has the “Join waitlist” option. Calendar/intranet materials: Because the time and room changed, update any calendar invitation, room reservation, registration page, or attached schedule—not just the announcement. Recording wording: The change from “all employees” to “registered attendees” is substantive, so make sure that access restriction is intentional. Deadline: The new deadline is October 8 at noon, one day and five hours earlier than the old deadline. Everything else in the new version is consistent with the old announcement, with the addition of the slides information.
Gemini · 2026-09-18 09:02-09:03 KST
I'm updating our team's internal workshop announcement. Compare the old and new versions and tell me what changed and what I should update before sending it to colleagues. OLD VERSION Team workshop — October 16, 2026 The workshop runs from 9:00 a.m. to noon in Room 204. Check-in opens at 8:30 a.m. Register by October 9 at 5:00 p.m. using the intranet form. Capacity is 40 people. Bring your laptop. Loaner laptops are available if requested when registering. Send dietary requests to [email protected] by October 12. If the workshop is full, you will automatically join the waitlist. The recording will be available to all employees for 30 days after the workshop. NEW VERSION Team workshop — October 16, 2026 Capacity is 40 people. Register by October 8 at noon using the intranet form. The workshop runs from 9:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. in Room 402. Check-in opens at 8:30 a.m. Bring your laptop. Send dietary requests through the intranet form by October 12. If the workshop is full, select "Join waitlist" in the intranet form. The recording will be available to registered attendees for 14 days after the workshop. Slides will be available to all employees after the workshop. Key Changes Between Versions Registration Deadline: Shifted earlier, from October 9 at 5:00 p.m. to October 8 at noon. Workshop Duration: Extended by 30 minutes, now running 9:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. Location: Moved to Room 402 (previously Room 204). Dietary Requests Method: Now submitted via the intranet form, removing the [email protected] email route. Waitlist Process: Requires users to manually check "Join waitlist" on the form instead of automatic enrollment. Recording Access: Access is now restricted to registered attendees (down from all employees) and time-limited to 14 days (down from 30 days). New Materials Added: Slides are now explicitly provided to all employees post-workshop. Loaner Laptop Info: Removed entirely from the new text. Action Items to Update Before Sending Clarify Loaner Laptops: Decide if loaner laptops are no longer offered, or if that policy still exists and needs to be re-added to the announcement. Double-Check Intranet Form Fields: Ensure your intranet form has been updated to include the new "Join waitlist" checkbox and a dedicated Dietary Requests field before publishing the link. Highlight Shifted Deadlines: Emphasize the earlier registration cutoff (Oct 8 @ noon) in your email subject line or callout box so returning attendees don't rely on the old date. Confirm Access Restrictions: Verify with your IT or multimedia team that the recording portal can restrict access strictly to registered attendees for the 14-day window.
Claude · 2026-09-18 09:02-09:03 KST
I'm updating our team's internal workshop announcement. Compare the old and new versions and tell me what changed and what I should update before sending it to colleagues. OLD VERSION Team workshop — October 16, 2026 The workshop runs from 9:00 a.m. to noon in Room 204. Check-in opens at 8:30 a.m. Register by October 9 at 5:00 p.m. using the intranet form. Capacity is 40 people. Bring your laptop. Loaner laptops are available if requested when registering. Send dietary requests to [email protected] by October 12. If the workshop is full, you will automatically join the waitlist. The recording will be available to all employees for 30 days after the workshop. NEW VERSION Team workshop — October 16, 2026 Capacity is 40 people. Register by October 8 at noon using the intranet form. The workshop runs from 9:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. in Room 402. Check-in opens at 8:30 a.m. Bring your laptop. Send dietary requests through the intranet form by October 12. If the workshop is full, select "Join waitlist" in the intranet form. The recording will be available to registered attendees for 14 days after the workshop. Slides will be available to all employees after the workshop. 변경 사항 비교 항목 기존 변경 비고 시간 9:00~12:00 9:00~12:30 30분 연장 장소 204호 402호 호실 오타 아닌지 확인 필요 등록 마감 10/9 17:00 10/8 12:00 마감이 하루 이상 앞당겨짐 노트북 대여 등록 시 요청하면 대여 가능 문구 삭제됨 의도적 삭제인지 확인 필요 식이 요청 접수 이메일([email protected]) 인트라넷 폼 접수 채널 변경 — 폼에 해당 항목이 실제로 추가됐는지 확인 대기자 등록 정원 초과 시 자동 대기 폼에서 "대기자 등록" 직접 선택 자동→수동으로 절차 변경, 공지에서 강조 필요 녹화본 제공 전 직원 대상, 30일간 등록자 한정, 14일간 접근 범위·기간 모두 축소됨 — 가장 큰 변경점 자료(슬라이드) 언급 없음 워크숍 후 전 직원 공개 신규 추가 항목 발송 전 확인 필요 사항 노트북 대여 안내 누락 — 실수로 빠진 건지, 정책이 없어진 건지 확정 필요. 계속 제공한다면 문구 복원 권장. 호실 변경(204→402) — 실제 예약된 방과 일치하는지 재확인. 녹화본 축소(전 직원 30일 → 등록자 14일) — 정책 변경이 맞다면 공지에서 별도로 눈에 띄게 표시하는 게 좋음. 기존에 "전 직원 열람 가능"으로 알고 있던 동료들이 혼란스러워할 수 있음. 대기자 등록 방식 변경(자동→수동) — "정원 초과 시 폼에서 직접 대기자 등록을 선택하세요"처럼 행동 지침을 명확히 문장에 넣는 게 좋음. 그냥 "선택 가능" 정도로만 쓰면 놓치는 사람이 생길 수 있음. 등록 마감 단축 — 기존 대비 마감이 빨라졌으므로, 공지 발송 시점과 마감일 사이 여유가 충분한지 확인.